Harry Targ
(The rise of protests of all kinds, within the United States and around the world, represents a contemporary manifestation of resistance against cruel and exploitative systems of power and control; capitalism being the most central. Central features of protest include the uprisings of young people, women, people of color, so-called "illegals", trans people, and people with disabilities. It is not an exaggeration to suggest that protestors come from old and new working classes; those who produce value that is expropriated by capitalists or are low paid or occasional workers who are the pool of underemployed and underpaid workers who drive down paid labor and drives to unionize. Given the root causes of protest and the prospects for expansion of Blue Waves the essay below revisits some older data and analyses of the working class in the twenty-first century. Class analysis remains central to understand what is happening now and how progresssives and socialists can most meaningfully give support to the resistance. Harry Targ, 11/19/2026)

Chapter Two
Introduction
Over
the last 25 years enormous changes have occurred in the global economy and in
national economies. Capitalism, which seemed on the verge of destruction during
the oil crises and economic stagnation of the 1970s, recovered and extended its
tentacles all across the globe, particularly as a result of the collapse of
Socialist regimes in Europe and Asia. During this time, the negative
consequences of capitalism generated massive mobilizations of workers, women,
indigenous peoples, and youth. However, capitalist institutions and armed
states have been able to repress and defuse revolutionary ferment while
extending neo-liberal economic policies everywhere.
Marx
argued that the material advances in capitalism-economic, scientific, and
technological-were historically unique as were the levels of misery,
marginalization, alienation, and victimization stimulated by them. The rise of
capitalism stimulated increased resistance to it; sometimes organized and
effective. However, when the Cold War ended, traditional movements opposed to
capitalism’s advance became confused, fragmented, and ineffective. Without the
anchor of a Socialist Bloc or revolutionary regimes or an ideologically and
institutionally coherent mass-based Socialist movement the organized Left began
to disintegrate into a broad array of separate issue-oriented groups. By the
late 1990s, however, massive and increasingly organized opposition to war, neo-liberal
globalization, racism, sexism, and homophobia began to spread throughout the
world. Despite this new resistance to the byproducts of global capitalism an
ideologically coherent anti-capitalist movement remains to be constructed.
Historically
the Marxist tradition has provided an analysis and rigorous understanding of
the capitalist system and has supplied theoretical tools for practical
political work. Therefore, it is critical to develop a Marxist theoretical and
historical analysis for our time. What is the nature of the capitalist mode of
production today? How is it different from what capitalism has historically
been? What remains the same today as was originally analyzed by Marx and his
followers? What
With
so much pain and suffering experienced all around us, it is of vital importance
to address these questions and to test out the answers that emerge in practical
political work. The materials below
respond to a variety of questions about theory, about capitalism, about
politics, and about political practice.
What Remains of Value in Marxist Theory?
Marx
grasped the underlying structures and dynamics of the capitalist mode of
production, the contradictions within it, and the possibilities for struggling
against its most negative features.
Several of his central hypotheses, still relevant today, are discussed
below.
First, the capitalist system is built on
the exploitation of the working class. Those who own or control the means of
production buy the labor power of the dispossessed, extracting the value of the
goods and services produced by workers. In short, value derives from human
labor power and it is appropriated by capitalists. Workers, whether
manufacturing or service, intellectual or manual, produce all wealth.
Second, because capitalists and workers
struggle for control of the value of the goods and services produced by
workers, class struggle is embedded in the economic system. Exploitation is not
primarily about the extraction of some excessive amount of labor by unusually
greedy and immoral capitalists. Rather exploitation is intrinsic to the
system. All existing societies were
based on the division between those who owned or controlled property and those
who did not. Therefore struggle between the rich and powerful and the poor is
intrinsic to class society. Class conflict is nowhere greater than in
capitalist societies.
Third, capitalism is a class system in
which the economic ruling class gains more
of the value of the product of labor and workers gain less; thereby the
entire system generates inequality. Often in history this inequality in
distribution of values has led to expanding misery of the masses of citizens of
a country.
Fourth, in a capitalist system, each
capitalist is compelled by the competitive nature of the economic system to
accumulate more capital. Capitalists expand their profits and accumulate more
capital or their enterprises are taken over by their competitors.
Fifth, capitalism breeds cutthroat
competition. Some capitalists accumulate more capital while others are forced
from participation in the system. Therefore, the general tendency of capitalist
competition historically has been a qualitative shift from huge numbers of
small economic units (central to the utopian “invisible hand” of Adam Smith) to
increasing concentrations of capital. As economic historian Douglas Dowd (1993)
put it, capitalism’s two fundamental dynamics are exploitation (as described
above) and expansion.
Expansion refers both to concentration of economic power in smaller numbers of hands and the spread of economic power over greater geographic areas. Lenin (1975) analyzed the historic evolution of capitalism from its industrial phase to its monopoly phase. He suggested that expansion led to colonies and neo-colonies. (In our own day capitalism has led to “globalization”). He added that expansion has also meant increasing control of economic sectors, then the overall economy, by a small number of multinational corporations and international banks. For him, imperialism was the monopoly stage of capitalism.
Sixth, the ownership class accumulates
more and more wealth and, therefore, typically that class also accumulates
enormous political power. The state usually represents the interests of the
ruling class but because of a variety of conditions or specific historical
contexts, the state often has become contested terrain; that is, workers and
their allies exercise significant influence over governmental policy.
Seventh, the capital accumulation
process leads capitalists to traverse the globe in pursuit of investment
opportunities, cheap labor, and customers for goods produced in the core
countries or in poorer countries, and vital natural resources, such as oil and
water. Overseas expansion by rich countries in support of their manufacturing
and financial capitalists, has stimulated the “globalization of capital” driven by, among other reasons, a tendency
for the rates of profit to fall and for capitalism to overproduce goods and
services that remain under-consumed within the country of origin.
Eighth, of all the contradictions
intrinsic to capitalism, the starkest is the historically evolving misery of
the masses. This is the general law of capitalism.
Finally, Marxism provides a method for
understanding the capitalist system, uncovering its mystifications, and
engaging in practical political activity to reform or overthrow it. The
methodology is historical, materialist, and dialectical.
Marx
counsels scholar/activists to seek to understand the world in its historical
context. The present is intimately tied to the past as the future is tied to
the present. Theoretical insights are “tested” in concrete historical
circumstances. In reconstructing the past, the historian analyzes the political
practice of a given time in terms of the context in which the political
activity occurred.
Marx
insists that there is a fundamental connection between the production and
reproduction of life, the organization of work, the distribution of wealth and
power, and the way people live, think, and act. Material conditions, i.e.
economics, frames politics, society, and culture.
In
addition, Marx claimed that the world is contradictory. The flowering new
capitalism of his day was creating its own gravediggers, workers. This economic
machine had buried within it the seeds of both growth and destruction. All of
life, even the human physiology of growth, is also movement toward death.
Political
analysts and political activists, therefore, must understand contradictions in
the real lived circumstances in which they are working. Concretely, activists
should remember that situations, political forces, movements, are neither all
one thing nor another, all good or all bad. And in our own day, the miseries of
global capitalism are generating the resistance and the visions of an
alternative way of living that can transform it.
Features of Late Capitalism

The
Belgian economist Ernest Mandel introduced the concept “late capitalism” in
writings on the economy in the 1970s. The Marxist literary scholar Fredric
Jameson borrowed the term to sub-title his book, Postmodernism or, the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (1991).
These authors claimed that capitalism had qualitatively changed from the
capitalist mode of production described by Lenin as “monopoly capitalism.” They
theorized about the changing character of capitalist production-what is
produced, by whom, with what technologies, and how the products are
distributed. Also, they claimed that the globalization, financial speculation,
and automation of the new capitalism had transformed what we typically call
culture- what we see, read, hear, consume, and believe.
The
concept “late capitalism” is useful because it suggests something about the
time in capitalism’s development historically; that capitalism may be
overdeveloped and hence subject to stresses, strains, and pressures for radical
change; that capitalism today is characterized by a variety of new features
requiring analysis; and that among these features are special kinds of economic
concentration, globalization, and cultural homogenization.
Informed
by basic insights from the Marxist tradition, theorists of “late capitalism,”
which today includes numerous writers on global capitalism, identify major
features of the contemporary political economy of capitalism.
First, capitalism, by any kind of measure, has become more concentrated than ever before in world history and the concentration has been particularly marked in the financial sector and in manufacturing. For example, Anderson and Cavanagh (Multinational Monitor) reported in 1996 that the top 200 corporations had combined sales exceeding the value of the Gross National Products, the value of all the goods and services produced in a country, of all but the nine wealthiest nations. By 2002, the sales of the top 200 corporations equaled 28 percent of the world’s GDP. In 2003, 52 of the top 100 economic actors in the world were corporations while 48 were nations. Wal-Mart was the nineteenth largest world economic actor, just below Belgium and ahead of Sweden. As Anderson, Cavanaugh, and Lee put it, “the largest 200 firms are the dominant engines of the global economy” (68). As to country of origin, Business Week ((July, 1998) presented data on the “global 1000” corporations. U.S. based corporations accounted for 480 of the 1,000, with European companies totaling 350.
In
1999 the assets of the twenty largest transnational banks exceeded $425
trillion (Kegley and Wittkopf, 227). Sixteen of them accounted for more than 60
percent of speculation in foreign exchange markets that year. As Greider and
others point out, financial speculation has been responsible for the severe
economic crises that have occurred in recent years, such as the Asian financial
crisis.
The
consolidation of economic power, in manufacturing, service, and finance
distinguishes the last 25 years from the prior 100 years. Functional activities
of the new super-corporations also have changed. Of the sales of the top 200
multinational corporations in recent years, half were in just five economic
sectors: trading and banking (financial), automobiles and electronics
(manufacturing), and retailing. Henwood reported that in 1991 finance,
insurance, and real estate (FIRE) surpassed the manufacturing contribution to
the US GDP for the first time. By 1996, the non-manufacturing sectors of the
economy accounted for $1.4 trillion in output while manufacturing totaled $1.3
trillion. Profits and sales derived from FIRE accounted for less than 20
percent of gross investment in 1950 and over 40 percent by 1990. On a worldwide
basis, 42 percent of the world’s stocks were held by U.S. financial
corporations in 1996 (Henwood, 1998).
Second, there have been significant
changes in capitalist relations of production and distribution over the last
thirty years from what some theorists refer to as “Fordism” to “Post-Fordism.”
Fordism refers to a system of production and distribution in which the working
class engages in the production of the largest quantity of commodities possible
using the latest assembly line techniques for distribution to as large a market
of consumers as possible. And, since the
workers themselves constitute the core consumers of the products produced, the
Fordist system assumed, workers must be paid a wage sufficient to purchase the
goods. In other words, the capitalist system that developed out of the
industrial revolution of the nineteenth century and expanded in the twentieth
century was based on high mass production and high mass consumption . Sectors
of the working class were paid a wage and received workplace benefits so that
they could afford to purchase the goods they were producing. The system was
called “Fordism” because Henry Ford believed he needed to provide a sufficient
wage for the workers he hired to build the Model T automobile for them to
purchase the cars they were producing.
The
Great Depression led to massive unemployment (25 percent of the work force).
Economists influenced by John Maynard Keynes recommended that more money needed
to be transferred to workers via state programs to stimulate demand and create
economic recovery. This logic was central to New Deal programs in the United
States and emerging social democracies in Europe both before and after World
War II. Some capital was transferred to workers as government
The
Fordist system was based on high mass production and high mass consumption.
Post-Fordism refers to a system of capitalist production that prioritizes a
higher, and smaller, income segment of the population for consumption of goods.
Products, including raw materials, capital goods, commodities for sale, are
produced in just enough quantity for a carefully targeted population.
“Just-in-time” production replaces mass production. Goods are produced based on
specific estimates of the number of products that will be sold. Shopping malls
and gentrified urban neighborhoods are the sites for targeting wealthier
consumers. Declining higher paying manufacturing jobs reduces the pool of
workers who can consume the goods produced. The Post-Fordist system is based on
super-exploitation of workers, often in overseas sweatshops, and the sale of
higher priced goods and services to smaller sectors of the population with
higher incomes than the traditional working class.
Obviously,
the process of targeting smaller higher income sectors of the working
population for consumption has not eliminated consumption by the working poor
and unemployed. All people are enticed to purchase allegedly cheaper goods from
retailers such as Wal-Mart. But increasingly consumerism is based upon
incurring debt. Consumer debt drives the Post-Fordist economy.
During the
1990s, total consumer debt for the first time exceeded total income in the
United States. Growing personal debt has gone up as government transfer
payments to poor and working people have declined. But, despite qualitative
increases in indebtedness, workers have trouble affording the goods produced.
Reduced demand for goods and services has led to reduced rates of profit from
manufacturing. To overcome declining rates of profit labor costs are reduced by
moving manufacturing to low wage poor countries. In addition multinational
corporations shift from investing in further manufacturing to financial
speculation. In the end, the loss of high paying manufacturing jobs has been a
significant byproduct of the Post-Fordist transformation of the relations of
production.
The
shift from Fordism to Post-Fordism is a tendency; a tendency that will make
sizeable and growing percentages of the working populations, of core capitalist
states as well as poor states, become obsolete as wage earners and consumers.
Survival of inner city youth, people of color, the aged, to masses of people in
Africa and Latin America requires
inventing ways to secure basic sustenance. So-called informal sector activities
become the means by which growing numbers of people (40 percent of working age
Latin Americans) avoid starvation. The shift from Fordism to Post-Fordism
mirrors the shift in global capitalism from manufacturing to service, the
movement of manufacturing capital to poor countries where workers work for
less, the rise of the informal sector, and growing joblessness and income and
wealth inequality around the world.
Third, with the growing concentration of
capital (in the United States and in the global economy), the surging
importance of financial (speculative) capital, the shift from Fordism to
post-Fordism and increasingly marginalized informal sector struggles for survival,
there has occurred a growing inequality in the distribution of wealth and
income. Gaps in wealth and income have been increasing for some thirty years in
the United States, and in the world at large.
Chart 1 derived from 2001 data presented by
Doug Henwood (2003) illustrates the magnitude of the gaps between rich and poor
in the United States.
Chart 1: Distribution of Income and Wealth in the United States, 2001
Bottom
90% Top 10% Top 1%
Income 61 39 14.5
Net Worth 31.2 69.9 32.7
Assets 35.5 64.6 29.5
Stocks 11.9 88.1 52.9
Bonds 4.2 95.8 64.4
Debts 73.8 26.1 5.9
While the top ten percent of the
income earners had “only” 39 percent of the nation’s income, it controlled 64.6
percent of its assets, 88.1 percent of its stock, 95.8 percent of its bonds,
and had only 26.1 percent of its debt.
The Economic Policy Institute reported that since 1983 the top one percent of wealth holders had 30-40 percent of the country’s wealth and the bottom 80 percent held only 16 percent,and for the last 40 years 80 percent of all wealth in American has been held by the top 20 percent of households (Mishel, Bernstein, and Boushey, 2003, 281). In 1979, the income of the top one percent was 33 times greater than the bottom 20 percent. By 1997, the top one percent had 88.5 times more income than the bottom 20 percent (73).
Persistent
and growing economic inequality has been noted around the globe as well. (Data
below and in Chapter 3 illustrate this). The United Nations Development
Program, which issues reports on global development and underdevelopment,
reported in the late 1990s that gaps between rich and poor countries and within
rich and poor countries had grown over the last several years and that at least
one quarter of the world’s population lived in poverty. A 2003 UNDP report
indicated that 54 countries were worse off economically than they had been ten
years earlier. Earlier reports suggested that less than 400 billionaires had
combined assets greater than annual incomes of countries with populations
totaling 45 percent of the world’s population (Rowan).
A
2005 UN reported called “The World Social Situation: The Inequality
Predicament,” indicated that the gaps between rich and poor peoples and
countries had grown over the decade since the Summit for Social Development in
1995. The report noted that 80 percent of the world’s Gross Domestic Product
was controlled by one billion people while 20 percent was shared by five
billion people. Nearly one quarter of working people in the world earned less
than $1 a day, the World Bank standard for extreme poverty. Nearly 3 billion
people lived on less than $2 a day. Global poverty, the report claimed, was
related to inequalities in literacy, health, jobs, and as well as to violence.
Fourth, despite modest improvements from
time to time the general living conditions of workers in the U.S. have been
eroding. Wages, working conditions, job security, hours of work, and numbers of
those living in poverty were worse in the mid-1990s than the 1970s, and despite
a short-term increase in wages in the late 1990s, the American worker in the
new century was not as well off as his counterpart of thirty years earlier. For
example, the percentage of the work force that earned at or below official
poverty levels grew from 23.5 percent in 1973 to 28.6 percent in 1997. The
percentage of Black workers earning poverty wages increased from 36.8 percent
to 3.8.2 percent in those years, and Hispanic workers from 34.3 percent to 46.7
percent. Male workers who had less than a high school education, a high school
diploma, some college or a college degree all earned less in real dollars in
1997 than they did in 1973. For women, those with a college degree earned more
in 1995 than in 1973 but the trajectory of real earnings was down for those
other women workers with some or no college (Michel, Bernstein and Schmitt,
1999, 136-142).
During the second Clinton administration, the
percent of workers earning poverty level wages declined but by 2003, the trend
was reversed. Those earning poverty level wages had gone up. Furthermore,
unemployment was two percentage points higher, 3.2 private sector jobs had been
lost, and real family income had declined in 2001 and 2002 (Mishel, November 3,
2003).
Monthly Review (April, 2003) addressed the recent impacts of the capitalist economy on U.S. workers. Over 2 million jobs were lost between 2001 and 2003. Eighty-seven percent of job losses became permanent (up from 50 percent in prior recessions). Layoffs of those who did eventually return to work were for longer periods than in the past. Real unemployment rates, including discouraged workers and involuntary part-time workers, were double the official rates. By any measure of unemployment, African American women and men experienced twice the loss of whites while Hispanic unemployment rates were 25 percent greater than those of whites. African-American and other minority youth experience up to five times greater unemployment than whites over age 25.
Additional
indicators reflected the stresses of the economy on people’s lives. Demands for
emergency food assistance, shelter, and welfare rose as government programs
were slashed. The Center on Budget and Policy priorities estimated that states
experienced almost $160 billion in budget deficits between 2001 and 2003 which
led to radical shortfalls in health care and resources for public education,
public safety, child care, and disaster relief in 2005 (2004)..
Exacerbating
growing inequalities and declining living conditions, the Bush administration
successfully lobbied for massive tax cuts for the rich which shifted more
wealth and income from the many to the few. In addition, the president lobbied
for radical reductions in all governmental services and the transfer of
programs formerly residing in the federal government to budget strapped states.
Every effort was made to privatize all public services- from education to
social security to welfare. The twenty-first century U.S. economy experienced
stagnation, declining real wages, and high unemployment, coupled with bloated
military expenditures. Every public program, except the military, was being
downsized. In 2005, economic and social
disaster was confounded by hurricane disaster.
Fifth, in the United States, the vast
majority of the population, largely the working class has been marginalized,
“deskilled”, and fragmented. On the one hand, the nature of work has been
transformed over the last 100 years to increase management control of every
phase of the work process. As Braverman suggested in the 1970s, much of the
conceptual organization of work and control over decisions about worker
behavior has been and continued to be transferred from the shop floor to the
CEO’s office. Braverman said that with applications of post-Taylorist worker
control techniques, the work force was steadily being reduced to simple bodily
motions. His/her work was “deskilled;” that is, the work was reduced to the
simplest of physical and mental behaviors.
Management had expropriated the power that came with knowledge of the
job. As the twentieth century evolved, entrepreneurial and craft skills were
destroyed and workers were transformed into deskilled factory and then service
workers. Loss of power and control manifested in work skills and the
homogenizing of all work activity meant that the more and more of the working
population had become proletarianized.
Proletarianization
meant that more and more workers activities were reduced to simple motions
under management control. One kind of worker was fundamentally similar to every
other kind of worker. Workers had become powerless and marginalized in the
capitalist system; a mass of homogenized bodies and minds.
It is critical to be aware of the
fragmentation of workers as well. For
example, the traditional industrial working class now constitutes less than
twenty percent of the work force. The largest share of the work force today is
in the service sector, from banking, to insurance, to health care, to fast
food. An increasing share of workers is acquiring computer skills and according
to some, for example Robert Reich, educating workers to become “symbolic
analysts” is necessary to overcome structural unemployment and declining real
wages. Fragmentation in the end refers to the differentiation of work into
numerous discrete activities and managerial control. Computerization has
advanced the process.
In addition, a significant share of the work force is contingent and/or made up of part-time employees. Manpower Incorporated, a personnel service that places temporary workers has been among the largest employers in the United States. Temps are often hired for factory jobs earning half the wages of their co-workers without any health and pension benefits. Ironically, temps sometimes train other temps or full-time replacements. Finally, the modern working class includes a significant percentage of working age men and women who are unable to gain jobs and who have to survive in the underground economy.
Fragmentation of
the work force, as with proletarianization, is the result of the changing means
and relations of production, The introduction of technology, just-in-time
production schemes, downsizing and shifting production overseas, Post-Fordist
policies, transforming work, the shift from production to service, and
decentralizing production facilities and service outlets all materially have
refashioned the relations of production. In addition, fragmentation of the
working class in late capitalism is reinforced by the perpetuation and use of
racism, sexism, and homophobia by capital. Lack of access to jobs and pay
equity, and under-representation in labor unions, attacks on affirmative
action, and raising the “threat of immigration,” all effectively drive a wedge
between sectors of a working class that is already divided by virtue of changes
in the means of production. In other words, the world of the worker in the
United States and globally is one of marginalization, proletarianization, and
fragmentation.
Contradictions
in the Political Economy of Capitalism Today
As
suggested at the outset, Marx advanced a method for understanding and acting on
the world that was historical, materialist, and dialectical. A central element
of this method was the use of the idea of “contradiction.” In simple terms it
suggested to analysts that they look for the seeds of opposing tendencies and
phenomena embedded in social processes; that no social process, development, or
institution could be characterized as either one thing or another. The world of
social and political relations was a complex world and analysis and
political activity required the subtle reading that exploring
contradictions required. It is argued here that contradictions of the political
economy of late capitalism bear upon progressive politics
First,
the concentration of capital has reached levels unparalleled in human history.
This means smaller numbers of corporations and banks control more and more of
economic relations within countries and between them. However, this
concentration of capital has accelerated competition between these corporations
and banks such that the struggle for survival of parts of the global political
economy, and the entire capitalist political economy, is more desperate as the
years pass. This means that corporations and banks are in contradiction with
each other and capitalist states are in competition with each other even as the
biggest economic actors consolidate their economic control across borders.
For
example, the movement toward “free trade” is supposed to create one global
economy embodied in the World Trade Organization. However, this vision of a
global trading network has stimulated the creation of regional trade regimes
such as the North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), the European Union, and
the Asian Pacific Economic Cooperation organization. In the long run regional
trade might increase competition and conflict between the United States in the
Western Hemisphere, Europe, and Asia.
Within the United States, economic concentration is reflected in the declining numbers of individuals and corporations that control more and more of the wealth of the country. Competition among huge corporations exists even though the rule of capital is hegemonic. Competition and disintegration is reflected also in struggles among those capitalist organizations whose interests are global in competition economically and politically with capitalist organizations that derive their profits from largely internal sources (real estate interests, energy corporations, retail trade, and service corporations).
Second, late
capitalism is characterized by extraordinary scientific and technological
achievements. From instantaneous communication, to the computerization of
production, to the production of products using skills of workers from several
countries simultaneously, to transplant surgeries, to genetic engineering,
humans have the capacity to eliminate onerous and dangerous physical labor,
reduce the incidence of disease, cure heretofore deadly diseases, feed the
world, and empower people politically and culturally. And, by virtue of global
media, the world’s citizens are aware of these human potentials. However, the
reality is that the new technology, the new “globalization,” has created the
opposite, human misery. Marx’s general law of capitalism seems as true today as
in his day.
Third, late
capitalism has ushered in significant increases in worker productivity so that
smaller percentages of the workers than used to be needed to dig coal, make
steel, build automobiles, or cut meat now produce significantly greater
quantities of these goods. In macro-economic terms the percentage of higher
wage industrial workers within the United States has declined and been replaced
by lower paid service workers. Globally, significant shares of industrial
production have been shifted from high paying work forces in core capitalist
countries to very low paying work forces in poorer countries. The paradox of
increased worker productivity, coupled with declining high paying jobs and
income, is that more goods are being produced globally than can be consumed.
This creates the classic contradiction of capitalist economics reflected in
overproduction and under-consumption.
Further, the
growing contradiction of over-production and under-consumption parallels and
reinforces declining rates of profit, a tendency experienced by U.S. industrial
capital from the 1960s to the 1980s. With declining profit rates, capital
investment shifted from production to finance, including stocks, bonds, and
currency speculation. President Nixon’s withdrawal from the currency
regulations of the Bretton Woods system and, later, President Reagan’s tax cuts
for the rich also benefited the shift from investments in goods and services to
speculation. In general, global capitalism has shifted its priorities from
producing consumable goods and services to electronic buying and selling.
Meanwhile, the gaps between rich and poor grow, conquerable diseases spread,
and human misery expands. The neo-liberal agenda forces countries to downsize
their governments to attract foreign investors in industrial development at a
time when such investors become more and more scarce.
Even when
foreign investors invest in the productive apparatus of a nation, they may
precipitously shift speculative capital at the first hint of economic crisis.
This was visibly reflected in the deep economic crisis of 1997 that
destabilized East Asian “miracle” economies. Since over-production,
under-consumption, and financial speculation , and indebtedness are at the
heart of globalization and neo-liberalism, the entire global political economy
of the current period is “skating on thin ice.”
Fourth, a significant feature of late capitalism is a qualitative increase in the ability to communicate across long distances and instantaneously. World citizens have the capacity, as never before, to acquire information about politics, cultures, science, and human experience. This technological wizardly has the potential to liberate humankind from provincialism, to facilitate the transmission of cultural contributions to the storehouse of wisdom, to educate the young, and to increase democratic participation in political systems. However, the new technology has meant the destruction of cultures, the homogenization of human experience, and the concentration of communications institutions such that twenty or so media groups produce about half of what the world reads, sees, hears, and probably believes about economics, politics, and culture. Some writers, such as Benjamin Barber, argue that the only resistance now to the full McDonaldization of the globe comes from religious fundamentalisms; that there is a profound need for social movements to seize control and democratize the means of cultural production.
Fifth, a fundamental contradiction of
late capitalism is reflected in the character of the working class. On the one
hand, as suggested above, that class everywhere is more homogenized, deskilled,
and proletarianized than ever before. Braverman estimated in the 1970s that
about 85 percent of U.S. working age people could realistically be categorized
as working class whereas a century earlier the vast majority of those working
were farmers. Today, by virtue of wages and income, job and economic
insecurity, unhealthy conditions of work including speed-up and longer work
hours, people employed share more in common in Detroit, Tucson, Juarez,
Johannesburg, and Beijing than ever before.
On the other
hand, the working class is more fragmented than at any time in the history of
capitalism. This fragmentation includes job categories including production or
service work, various job tenures including full or part-time, and unionized or
non-union work sites. Most importantly, workers are divided by race, gender,
sexual orientation, age, country of birth, and immigration status (“legal” or
“illegal”). The material fragmentation is reinforced often by ideological
fragmentation: anti-communism, identification with right-wing groups including
militias and Christian fundamentalists, and single issue groups that organize
around guns or against women’s right to choose. Also large sectors of the
working class still see their futures tied to the electoral victories of the
Democratic Party yet remain overwhelmingly alienated from the political
process.
Challenges to Progressive Politics in the Era of Late Capitalism
This portrait of
late capitalism suggests several contradictions: the concentration of capital
and intensifying conflict between sectors of capital; advancing science and
technology and rising human misery; overproduction and under-consumption;
monopoly control of a globalizing cultural apparatus and religious/cultural
resistance to it; and an homogenization and fragmentation of the working class.
These features suggest that global capitalism is integrating and disintegrating
at the same time. For example:
-Global capitalism is increasingly dominated by a few hundred banks and corporations in a handful of countries and a few international financial organizations while the wealthy countries, dominant corporations and banks, and even the leading international financial organizations, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank, engage in growing economic and political competition.
-Political
forces in the United States representing international capital contest public
policies with sectors of capital that represent domestic economic
interests.
-Conflict
over state economic policies stimulates class fractions to appeal to different
constituents among the marginalized. Thus, culture wars emerge as ruling class
fractions appeal to more “liberal” or more “conservative” sectors of the
majority populations of the country. Out of this maelstrom comes religious
fundamentalism, single issue political struggles-such as anti-abortion and
pro-gun campaigns and a politics centered around so-called “family values.”
-Conflicts
in international relations among powerful states, mostly capitalist, emerge
over how the international system should be controlled. The United States has
moved to establish a post-Cold War military hegemony (“the last remaining
superpower”) which has generated conflict with other nations over issues
ranging from the war on Iraq, to land mines, to global warming, to the Cuban
embargo, to trade preferences.
Metaphors
of centrifugal and centripetal forces, accommodation and resistance,
cooperation and conflict, and consolidation and disintegration apply very well
to political economy in the era of late capitalism. In fact, the forces tearing
apart capitalism are as intense as ever before. The vivid metaphors of growth
and decay that were so dramatically expressed in The Communist Manifesto can help in understanding the contradictions of contemporary capitalism
and the possibilities of radical social change everywhere.
Paradoxically,
the working class is as fettered with the forces of disintegration, disarray,
and conflict, as is late capitalism.
One need only list elements of the fragmentation of the working people
of the planet to understand the difficulties progressives face in building mass
movements for fundamental change.
-Racism,
the most divisive force in the history of the United States, remains virulent.
Powerful politicians can talk about using abortion to reduce the numbers of
Black babies, which, in the long run, would reduce the crime rate. On a global
level, the United States can bomb people of color and make war on them with
impunity and large percentages of the citizenry endorse and support the actions
(at least for a time).
-Sexism remains institutionalized in work, in politics, in personal relationships, and in culture. Gains for women in public institutions have largely been made on capitalism’s own terms so that popular culture celebrates the few women who break through the “glass ceiling.” At the same time, the instruments of mass culture and education trumpet the virtues of the nuclear family, “stay-at-home moms,” images of women still as primary caregivers for children, male partners, and the aged and poor. Meanwhile, working class women, particularly women of color, bear the heaviest burdens of the capitalist system and receive the least support from it. And, in the political arena, women’s issues are marginalized rather than seen as part of the politics of the working class as a whole.
-Homophobia has become a major source of divisiveness among working people as gays and lesbians have asserted their rights to sexual preference and personal and political freedom. Right-wing politicians use issues such as gay marriage as lighting rods to divide the electorate. And paradoxically, movements to struggling against homophobia sometimes conceive of their activities separate from or instead of struggles for Socialism and the liberation of all working people. Consequently, sectors of the gay and lesbian movement and also African American and women’s movements mobilize around identity issues to the exclusion of class issues. This occurs while those movements that are characterized more by class perspectives consciously choose to side-step identity issues, or, even worse, reject the concerns for racism, sexism, and homophobia.
-The politics of social and
economic transformation-as reflected in the socialist and communist movements
of the early 1900s and the 1930s and the New Left of the 1960s-has been
replaced by the politics of single issues. Progressives organize in groups around
anti-war, nuclear, environmental, Central American, anti-IMF, living wage, and
other single issues. Usually, such groups do not contextualize their issue
mobilizations
in broader class,
anti-racism, and anti-sexism perspectives and more generally the struggle for
socialism. Mass movements have become fragmented into a thousand different
issue domains.
-The rightwing sectors of the
economic ruling class have utilized the politics of the single issue to
mobilize around so-called “culture wars” issues-anti-abortion, anti-gun
control, school vouchers, anti-pornography- such that working people are drawn
into emotionally charged campaigns that separate them from their brothers and
sisters and thus fragment the working class. In many parts of the United
States, working people vote for candidates on the basis of their stand on guns
even as economic inequality, job loss, and declining income make their personal
lives more painful. Nationally, working people are fragmented by differences in
geography, economic context, local political culture, and political possibilities.
Struggles around “free trade,” living wage campaigns, immigration, vary by
state and region.
-Finally, the left, broadly
defined, disintegrated over the last twenty years, particularly after the
collapse of socialism. Traditional left parties deconstructed. Left
intellectuals embraced various kinds of “post-Marxist,” “post-modernist,”
“post-colonial” formulations of the contemporary crisis. Some progressives
rejected all of their history after the collapse of the Soviet Union. They
called for a totally new beginning; in short they rejected history and
theoretical traditions. Others embraced new theoretical formulations, such as
some variant of the “globalization” thesis that demands “new age” thinking.
Finally, many progressive intellectuals rejected the older organic connection
between intellectuals and the working class.
In sum, late capitalism is an era
in the development of the mode of production in which growth and decay,
assimilation and disintegration, consolidation of economic and political power and
growing conflicts among its parts all are magnified. In terms of the relations
of production, workers are more homogenized, deskilled, and controlled while
they are fragmented in terms of jobs and job security, unionization, race,
gender, sexual orientation, geography, ideology, culture, and politics. The challenge for 21st century
progressives is to understand the decay of late capitalism and the
opportunities it provides for social change and to develop strategies to
overcome the fragmentation of the global working class.
Anderson, Sarah and John
Cavanagh. “Corporate Empires,” Multinational
Monitor, December, 1996, http://multinationalmonitor/org/hyper/min
1296.00.html
Braverman, Harry. Labor and Monopoly Capital, Monthly
Review, 1973.
Business Week. July, 1998.
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. “A Brief Update
on State Fiscal Conditions and the Effects of Federal Policies on State
Budgets,” September 13, 2004, www.cbpp.org/9-13-04
sfp.htm
Dowd, Douglas. U.S. Capitalist Development Since 1976. Of,
By, and for Which People. M.E. Sharpe, 1993.
Greider, William. One World Ready or Not, Simon and
Schuster, 1997.
Henwood, Doug. After the New Economy, The New Press,
2003, 123.
Henwood, Doug. Wall Street. Verso, 1998, 56-117.
Jameson, Fredric. Postmodernism or the Cultural Logic of Late
Capitalism, Duke University, 1991.
Kegley, Charles W. and Eugene R.
Wittkopf. World Politics: Trend and
Transformation, St. Martin’s Press, Boston, 2001.
Lenin, “Imperialism: the Highest
State of Capitalism,” in Robert C. Tucker ed. The Lenin Anthology, Norton, 1975, 204-275.
Litaer, Bernard. “From the Real
Economy to the Speculative,” IFG News,
published by the International Forum on Globalization online at Third World
Network.
Mishel, Lawrence. “Grading the Jobs and Growth Plan,”
Economic Policy Institute, November 3, 2003, www.epi.org/policy/grading_jobs_and_growth_plan,
pdf
Mishel, Lawrence, Jared
Bernstein, and Heather Boushey. The State of Working America, 2002/2003,
Cornell University Press, 2003, 277-307.
Mishel, Lawrence, Jared
Bernstein, and John Schmitt. The State of Working America, 2000/2001, Cornell
University Press, 2001.
Mishel, Lawrence, Jared
Bernstein, and John Schmitt, The State of
Working America, 1998-1999, Cornell University Press, 1999, 119-218.
Rowan, David. “UN Report Says One
Billion Suffer Extreme Poverty,” World Socialist Web Site, July n28, 2003, www.wsws.org/articles/2003/jul.2003/unp-j28_prn.shtml
The Editors, “What Recovery?” Monthly Review, April, 2003.
United Nations Department of
Social and Economic Affairs, The World
Social Situation: The Inequality Predicament, UN, New York, 2005.
